Home › Forums › Controversial Topics › How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah › Reply To: How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah

#1027941
Sam2
Participant

PBA: Safek Sakanah is a Kol Shehu. Even Echad Mini Elef.

And that’s your response? Not enough babies die? That’s ridiculous. It’s retarded. Should I say that I’m Pattur for going into a maternity ward and start attacking one out of every thousand babies with a hatchet because without medical care more than that would have died anyway? That’s stupid. It’s beyond stupid. It’s the dumbest thing you’ve ever said. If we can prove that this is life-threatening, then it’s life-threatening. Period. End of discussion.

Rant aside, I’m not saying ban MBP. But if Mohalim don’t know not to do it when they have a cold sore and we can’t get them all not to, then banning MBP might be the only choice.