Arso > You, philosopher, have no right to decide how to learn pshat in Rashi since you did not go through the cheder-yeshivah experience. And you certainly have no right to argue with the Or Hachayim or the Rif on the Ein Yaakov
I did not follow your argument, but this statement per se is outrageous. Here is a learned lady bringing an argument and you are using invalid logical arguments to put her down. Could you just analyze her statement per se? Maybe you did somewhere else. You also seem to support R Soloveitchik position for coed Torah classes – his thinking was that separate classes will lead to inferior education. (I think he was right for the time and communities he dealt with, not necessarily true now). Your statement seems to mean that you think girls in your community get worse education in meforshim.