Reply To: The antizionism amongst religious Jews has no legitimate detractors

@always_ask_questions
while I appreciate the respectful response, your are not being very honest.

you wrote:

I suggested reading up on R Soloveitchik books and see what you think about that. Others suggested other authors. Maybe the disconnect is that you are looking for a one-page disproof of Vayoel Moshe?

There is wide space between “go learn and figure it out on your own” and “you expect a one-page proof?”. Neither of those are fair or honest if you claim that, chalila, “Zionism is a mainstream Torah shita”.

I’m not playing games in my question, but I am again left emptyhanded in what should be a straightforward request:: what is this “zionist shita in Torah”? [at risk of adding too much words: I don’t mean I want CR opinions, I mean a real bona fida authoritative published Torah shita.]

Again, to be clear, the Shulcha Aruch (and the general derech hapsak) demands a posek explain his novel reasoning for the public and show the talmudic sources that he claims obligate the public to listen. But, seriously, you HAVE NOTHING but claim you have a solid Torah foundation?