simcha613:
Your claims are not based in reality. Jews lived in Eretz Yisrael long before the Zionists invaded in the early 20th century, and well before they declared their “State” in 1948. As well, Jews throughout the ages tangibly expressed their ahavas haAretz by moving there, including the Or HaChaim HaKadosh hundreds of years ago and many, many, many others.
The Zionist “State” has destroyed more Torah than anything else in history. They’ve shmaded at least three generations of Jews, numbering in the millions of people!! The yeshivos there exist despite the Zionists, not because of them. The biggest supporter of Torah currently is actually the Russian President, not the Zionists.
No, the “medina” is not only far from perfect, it is an abomination and massive rebellion against G-d. And it has shmaded generations of Jews as mentioned. If any secular country in the world were to do even a fraction of what the wicked Zionists do to the Jews there, everyone would be yelling about it non-stop. So, to claim as you did that we are “better off with the medina” is both absurd (on a practical level) and heresy: we are always better off following G-d’s wishes, not massively rebelling against him as the Zionist “State” was, is and does.
You are also totally misrepresenting the origins of Zionism. The express purpose of Zionism always was and remains today: change Judaism from a Torah-based religion to an anti-G-d idolatrous nation-state-based “religion”.
Hashem did not choose to grant any yeshuos through the Zionists. Hashem did listen to those who prayed for the Zionists and did give them success, to the tremendous detriment of Jews worldwide. “We” do not have a medina. “We” do not have E”Y. We could have visited E”Y before the Zionists came, and could have lived there before then, too. The Zionists have wreaked havoc and cataclysmic destruction there in E”Y.
It is shocking that above even has to be written and is not already obvious to all.