Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Hi I�m back 3.0 Reply To: Hi I�m back 3.0

#2430857
yankel berel
Participant

@qwerty
@non political

The word nevu’a has been used in many formats

habad claims that their late leader is a navi as in the biblical format

re a biblical navi , it says that someone not listening to his directive that is hayav mitah biydei shamayim [if remember correctly]

in addition a biblical navi is authorised to suspend temporarily any mitsva except for avoda zara

smag one of the leading rishonim says clearly that this biblical full fledged nevu’a has stopped with hagai zharya and malachi [part of trei asar]

rambam spells out criteria for acceptance of biblical nevua

habad’s claims for biblical nevua are clearly disproven by rambams criteria
.

as opposed to biblical nevu’a , any later use of the term nevu’a pertains to the lower leve non biblical nevu’a, which

does not mandate anyone to listen and is not subject to admission criteria as per rambam .

important to keep this stinction in mind whenever

discussing habad’s leaders claim to biblical authority to command any jew to listen on pain of mitah byedei shamayim

and his claim to the authority to suspend temporarily any mitsva except for avoda zara

are not to be taken lightly at all

these are very major discussions to be had
.
.