Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Rabbi Moshe Hillel Hirsch and the IDF (Israeli Army) Reply To: Rabbi Moshe Hillel Hirsch and the IDF (Israeli Army)

#2432850
yankel berel
Participant

ujm , somjew and katan are owing still….

they have not responded to –
how three times tur mehaber plus nosei keilim are subservient in halacha lemaaseh to maharal not brought anywhere lehalacha

they have not responded to –
clear blame for terrible happenings ,like harugei betar, is due to the disconnection from the rbsh�o , instead of on the oaths, according to avnei nezer and by extension, all standard halacha sefarim like sh�a and nosei keilim , AS DULY NOTED BY AVNEI NEZER himself

they have not responded to –
the clear reality in front of us in the middle east AS IT IS NOW , not as it supposedly was once, and without any dishonest sidestepping and totally irrelevant blame game how things could or should have been

they have not responded to –
the factual and clear evidence that many people served in IDF without being shmadded and why that should not be taken into account when deliberating in one particular case where this individual�s refusal to show up , will have pikuach nefesh repercussions

they have not responded to –
clear evidence that the majority of haredei talmidei hahamim and tsadiqim, totally rejected their singular focus on historical transgressions of the oaths [according to the holkim on avnei nezer] as the source of all evil

they have not responded to –
the obvious reality , clear to any astute ten year old , that the majority of talmidei hahamim for the last eighty years , by their PASSIVE non participation in the demonization of the State per se, EVEN IF IT WERE TOTALLY FRUM , disagree [with this satmar obsession equating zionism to xtianity]

they have not responded to –
the implicit charge to why they think that they understand

torah ,

reality, and

torahs application to said reality,

better than all aforementioned t�ch and tsadiqim

in summary they have a lot to respond to which they did not do yet

we will see whether we will be zoche to receive TO THE POINT , HONEST and FULL responses without sidestepping
.
.
.