@AAQ
yankel> don�t see any connection to �no true scotsman� in any of my writings �
aaq > I meant that � in this case � you seem to only consider chachamim those who agree with your opinion.
—
Incorrect.
I treat both SR and r YB soloveitchik with reverence.
Both were chachamim .
Both were outliers and clearly a minority amongst the chachamim in their views.
—
What I am saying , and you did not address , is the current draft .
All chachamim seeing the current draft problem with all its current realities and all its repercussions , agree not to enlist ..
aaq disagrees ….
..
.